5-minute read

Organizing people is hard. Workplaces create policies and procedures to establish order and set expectations. That’s what’s written.

Then there’s human behavior, shaped by implicit and explicit hierarchies and ambition. Human behavior is what’s done.

Understanding and addressing gaps between what’s written and what’s done helps develop adaptable policies and behavioral guidelines that support positive shifts in organizational culture.

The first assumption to address is that policies are static. That’s understandable: creating a policy takes a lot of work, and once it’s done, we want to check the box and move on. When we treat policies as static documents rather than guidance that aligns expectations with how people interact, they can quickly become outdated and ineffective. Example:

Written vacation policy: Unlimited
The idea behind the policy: Create a welcoming environment where team members have autonomy over their work, are trusted to deliver, and are supported in work-life balance.

Unwritten vacation reality: No one takes vacation because taking vacation is viewed as a lack of commitment to the company.

Understanding and closing the gap between what we write and how our teams work reimagines policymaking as an organic activity that supports positive organizational culture.

 

Run an experiment

Choose one policy as a test case. Policies on performance expectations, onboarding, and perks are good choices because the gap between what’s written and what’s done is often most apparent.

Begin with what is proven about the leading factors that cause people to leave an organization:

  1. Inability to work with manager
  2. Lack of career pathing
  3. Compensation

Now, look at your policies. Do they outline the support, training, and career pathing available to employees? Pay special attention to policies that support middle-manager development, as they are the direct interface with line staff.

If retention isn’t an issue for your organization, an employee satisfaction survey can help you identify any policy-versus-norm gaps.

 

Conduct an informal norm audit

With the chosen policy, conduct an informal survey across staff levels to see whether the policy supports all levels of the organization.

Using the vacation example, the norm may be for lower-level staff not to take vacation to ‘prove’ themselves, reserving unlimited vacation for managers and upper-level staff. Here, an explicit vacation policy with a ‘use it or lose it’ clause gives staff the air cover to take vacation without guilt.

Questions to ask in your informal audit: Do you understand this policy? How does it apply to your role? Have you relied on this policy? If so, what does it look like in practice for you and your team? Does this policy add, detract, or is neutral in supporting your team and creating a positive work culture?

 

Encourage norm conversations in 1-1 meetings

As an ongoing pressure test of your policies, encourage your managers to ask about norms versus policies in 1-1 meetings.

Guiding questions for middle managers: This is the policy on X; from where you sit, is it realistic? Does it support or hinder your ability to do your work?

Gather feedback to understand whether workplace practices have shifted and warrant policy adjustments.

 

Schedule an annual or biannual policy versus norm scan

With manager feedback, an annual or biannual policy-versus-norm scan will keep you in touch with how your team works and help you be more responsive to emerging trends.

Organizations grow, shrink, and change to fit client needs and market demands. These conditions make work fun and interesting. Your workforce adapts in real time, and, with some attention, your policies can too.

 

Thank you for reading.
If someone forwarded this and it was helpful,
please sign up and share freely.

 

Give the gift of a successful career launch